54 SAMS Business Models have been developed by start-ups, SMEs and students in different business development activities supported by the project partners UNPAD, ICEADDIS, UNILV, UNIKAS, UNIGRA. The SAMS Business Models range from honey reselling, digital marketplaces, beekeeping supply, beekeeping products for health and beauty to tourism, education and technology incl. remote monitoring beehives, DSS, PCB, data warehouse, etc.
D2.4 – Evaluation of Business Plans *Deliverable has not been approved and accepted by the EC
D2.5 – Evaluation of Business Licenses in Place or in Formation *Deliverable has not been approved and accepted by the EC
The following tables list the SAMS Business Models:
SAMS Business Models in Ethiopia
|Business Model Name and Start-Up Name||Contact Person||Summary||Business Model Canvas|
|Anabi by Anabi||Abiye Tadeos||Anabi directly sells smart beehives at lower prices for partner beekeepers, and smart beehives (beehives with monitoring and decision support systems) will be rented to crop growers. The leasing will take place during the flowering period. Anabi provides its system for partner beekeepers throughout the year. Anabi also sells bee products, particularly mono-floral honey for the global market with negotiation to its partner beekeepers.||BMC|
|MbeeHive by MbeeHive||Andualem Lemecha||MBeeHive is a low-cost new kind of modern hive, that enable harvesting extracted honey directly from the beehive. It will be bought by beekeepers for 2,500 Birr at the MBeeHive shop in order to increase honey productivity almost averagely by 3.5X and get high-quality nectar honey with much less time and cost.||BMC|
|Daemat by Daemat||Kisanet Haile Molla||Farmers do not have a convenient way of selling their products to consumers; instead, they deliver them to middlemen brokers and wholesalers who buy the agricultural products at ridiculously exploitative prices. As a result, farmers don not get the income they should get out of the harvested products. Price volatility due to supply seasonality, lack of market information, loss of quality products during inconvenient transportation of the products is the main issue in the food value chain. Daemat is a digital market platform that allows agricultural product producers to directly sell their products to consumers and gain better financial benefits.||BMC|
|Kekros by Kekros Ethiopia||Negasa Berhanu||Kekros Ethiopia expects to engage in multiple apiculture business sectors in Ethiopia –
developing a website to give online beekeeping training for agricultural professionals and beekeepers to improve their production quality and quantity, manufacturing supply beekeeping inputs like a quality beehive for beekeepers, designing and developing a beehive monitoring system for beekeepers and researchers, producing quality honey and beeswax for local and export market using its own products and services lines.
|Birzz by Yiblu||Azeb Assefa||Birzz is an alternativ healthy energy drink. Birzz will be bought and used by any one at any young age at retail outlets or directly from the Birzz online store in order to boost daily energy with a healthy drink.||BMC|
|Awsome Africa||Meraf Theodros||Awsome Africa helps local apiculture enterprises or individual producers to prosper themselves by giving them easy access to highly established disciplines and techniques of organic and high yield honey production. As well as to help them to take the best advantage of those skills, increase the quality and quantity of their production. It also provides supply chain facilitation services for beekeepers.||BMC|
|Bee Colony Transportation Tool||Teshome Erge||The bee colony transportation tool is an affordable and efficient equipment for transporting a small number of bee colonies from apiaries to other apiaries and to the bee colony market.||BMC|
|Ethiopian Honey and Beeswax Producers Exporters Association||Alemseged Gebrekidan||Ethiopian Honey and Beeswax Producers Exporters Association is an institution that helps local honey producers and processors to reach to the export global market. Besides that it provides professional consultancy and capacity building activities for beekeepers and honey processors.||BMC not available|
|Samuel Livestock production||Samuel Taye||Samuel Livestock production is a start-up producing honey mix with fruit marmalade, distributing the product with competitive price.||BMC not available|
|Mareg and Fanta||Mareg Franta||Mareg and Fanta is a honey sourcing and packaging company. This SME serves several types of honey from local regions and sells the honey in the urban market.||BMC not available|
|SmartHive||ICEADDIS team||SmartHive is a business manufacturing an all in one smart hives (ready sensors installed hives) and distribute smart hives as a business.||BMC|
|Mar-Tera||ICEADDIS team||Mar-Tera is a physical and digital beekeeping market place to bring and connect all stakeholders of the beekeeping sector including beekeeping equipment (hives, frames, suits, honey extractor, tools etc.), bee products (nectar, beeswax, pollen, bee bread propolis, royal jelly etc.) and apiculture service providers.||BMC|
|NibFinance||ICEADDIS team||NibFinance raises funds and invest in entrepreneurs and start-ups who are working in the apiculture industry.||BMC|
|EneMar||ICEADDIS team||EneMar is a bee education framework which is a holistic system to promote the culture of beekeeping by setting up beekeeping modules in schools and beekeeping clubs, trainings and certifying beekeepers. EneMar also provides a mapped value chain of beekeeping and stakeholders for better market value of bee products.||BMC|
|BeeQ||ICEADDIS team||BeeQ is a business to set up and certifying bee product quality standards. This will help fitting honey adulteration and improves consumer trust on bee products.||BMC|
|NibFM||ICEADDIS team||NibFM is a radio show for beekeepers and all stakeholders of the beekeeping sector. The station will provide information for beekeepers and stakeholders in the industry on topics like best practices, weather forecast, pollination time and market prices.||BMC|
|Ai1H||ICEADDIS team||Ai1H is a concept beehive that allows the beekeeper to harvest bee products as finished material from the hive.||BMC|
|BeeGraden||ICEADDIS team||BeeGraden is a holistic approach to specialty bee products production by setting up beehives around specialized gardens to guarantee the production of premium bee products.||BMC|
|BeeBlock||ICEADDIS team||BeeBlock is a digital platform to build on top of a block chain that guarantee bee product quality.||BMC|
|BeeBuzz||ICEADDIS team||BeeBuzz is a technology that enables communication with bees using special radio signals communicating flower and garden location to optimize the production rate.||BMC|
SAMS Business Models in Indonesia
|Business Model Name and Start-Up Name||Contact Person||Summary||Business Model Canvas|
|Masagi by Masagi||Ina Sawitri||Masagi is a product of the empowerment of beekeepers in Indonesia, housewives around the production house, and actively participates in environmental conservation efforts. Honey purchased from beekeepers will be processed by housewives whom empowered by conducting training in production honey-derived products and conducting good manufacturing practice and some of product’s profit are used for environmental conservation. Masagi produces honey derived products such as honey jam, various honey cookies, Honey Lemon Ginger syrup, and others.||BMC|
|Madu Cantik (MaCan) by Herbal Khansa||Adi Wira S.||Madu Cantik (Macan) is pure honey concoctions selected specifically from the taste, texture and nutritional that is very good for overcoming various skin problems. The products that Madu Cantik (Macan) offer is herbal skincare that is made from honey.||BMC|
|Laduni Mutiara by Apiary Laduni Mutiara||Abul Kodir
|Laduni Mutiara Lestari is a group of Apis mellifera beekeepers from Cianjur, West Java. It has about 300 colonies that have never been in Cianjur due to the absence of sufficient bee food. Have a dream to have a location for beekeepers in Cianjur and have started looking for cooperation with local government agencies to be able to use land that has not been utilized.
In marketing, they have collaborated with various local business owners in Cianjur to become a location for selling honey. In addition, he is also active in activities held by the West Java Provincial Forestry Service. One example was a participant in the Thrive Project, a project that was born from the collaboration of the Social Corporate Law Society (Socolas), Mongabay Indonesia (website from the US), The Local Enablers (a community from Unpad), IKA SKMA Jabar, and the West Java Provincial Forestry Service.
|Madu Hanjuang by Madu Hanjuang||Aulia Sofia N.||Madu Al Amin Hanjuang is raw honey that only goes through a filtering process and does not undergo any heating, centrifugal, or other processing processes.
Quality is guaranteed because it is obtained from selected honey suppliers, passing the quality test (SNI) in three trusted laboratories. This honey can also be eaten directly or as a food / beverage sweetener.
Travelable packaging, which is easy to carry anywhere, perfect to carry when you are on a trip all day, also at lunch.
Have a concentration on honey consumption that is guaranteed and affordable by many people. And want to make honey a unique Indonesian souvenir so that honey packaging is one of the points that want to be improved.
|Bandung Bee Sanctuary by CV. Suaka Lebah Bandung||Yoga R. Nugraha.||Bandung Bee Sanctuary is a beekeeping start-up that is selling honey, providing educational services, research and community empowerment. Types of bees that are cultivated include Apis cerana and Trigona laeviceps. There are five main concepts raised in this business, namely: Bee Farming, Edu Tourism, Social Innovation, & Eco Working Space.
Located around the city center of Bandung makes BBS an urban beekeeping. In addition, the land used by BBS is a land that is not utilized and even once became a waste disposal location. The location is then converted into a bee farm that can be planted with various types of flowers. The resulting impact of Bandung Bee Sanctuary activity is environmental preservation efforts through on abandoned critical land and becoming a landfill. Inaugurated on January 10, 2020 by the Chancellor of Padjadjaran University as a social entrepreneur based on conversation and eco-technology by prioritizing honey bee cultivation, ecotourism, and honey beekeeping training in improving quality of the environment and empowering the surrounding community.
|Bulema||Acep Jaelani||Bulema (budidaya lebah madu = honey bee cultivation) is a honey bee ecosystem with high economic value. There are several main concepts that have been raised in this business: Bee Farming, Edu Tourism, Social Innovation, and Beekeeping Education.
The impact of Bulema activities is an increase in public awareness of beekeeping and an increase in the capacity of new beekeepers / prospective beekeepers regarding the ability to implement beekeeping. Bulema collaborates with Bandung Bee Sanctuary in developing its business.
|Calakan||Rois Solihin||Calakan is a technology production house. A place for research and innovation in information technology that focuses on developing systems (web, mobile & API) and emerging technologies (Internet of Things, big data, etc.), which can produce technological solutions that have a social impact. The products that Calakan offers are consultation, software/website making, hardware construction, as well as IT system development services. One of their products is monitoring technology for Apis Cerana and assembled using a more affordable tech so the beekeepers will be able to afford this technology.||BMC|
|Honey Lab||M. Rifqi Fajriansyah||Honey Lab is a honey local product that concerns empowering local farmers with their sociopreneur company. They reinvest their profits to upgrade local farmers and their forest. The products that Honey Lab offer is honey made by local farmers, 100% pure honey from West Java Farm, farmer local product, green-social business concept.||BMC|
|Madu Baduy||Dede Sukriman||Madu Baduy is a social enterprise empowering the people of Baduy (local ethnic of Banten Province). Madu Baduy rebrands honey from people of Baduy so that other people know about beekeeping activities of people of Baduy. The product that Madu Baduy offers is forest honey. However, currently, this business is only focused on increasing product value in the packaging of its honey products.||BMC|
|Honeymu||Anggi Bagus R.||Honeymu is a honey local product that has its own beekeeping and offline store. They inform customers about convenience of being reseller, authenticity and honey availability, affordability and access to purchase. The products that Honeymu offers are mellifera/cerana honeycomb, bee pollen, raw honey and multiflora honey.||BMC|
|Gudang Lebah||Sutriyo.||Gudang Lebah is a wholesale center of bee products. They offer and inform people about pure products from bees. The products that Gudang Lebah offers are honey, royal jelly, bee pollen, propolis, and beeswax.||BMC|
|Jaga Lebah||Octy Viali Z.||Jaga Lebah is designed to be a community / start-up in Indonesia that focuses on bee conservation efforts through various ways. The main aim of Jaga Lebah is to increase people’s understanding of the importance of bees for life, especially among children and young people in urban areas. Jaga Lebah also has slogan “Bee as a Pet”, it uses trigona (stingless bee) as their main product.||BMC|
|Madu Bina Apiari||Dianita K. Kartika.||Madu Bina Apiari is a local honey product that empowers local forest beekeepers and already in beekeeping business since 1980. They concern the production of honey from beekeepers and train them about good beekeeping practices. The products that Madu Bina Apiari offers are honey, bee pollen, bee bread, and royal jelly.||BMC|
|Madu Primary||Dandi Budiman||Madu Primary is a brand used to sell and rebrand honey products by a start-up called Primary Agro. Primary Agro acts as a reseller in supply chain. Honey obtained from local beekeepers. Some types of honey sold by Primary Agro include honeycomb, forest honey, caliandra honey and multiflora honey.||BMC|
|Bio-N-Propolis is a propolis product based on research in Laboratorium. The raw material is produced by bees Tetragonula spp. which is maintained directly by the Bio-N Team, in collaboration with local farmers. Bio-N is a start-up company in health and beauty products that has its root from the research and innovation activities carried out at the Institute of Technology of Bandung (ITB). The name Bio-N derived from Bio-Engineering or Bio-Natural which highlights the importance of natural essence in producing health and beauty products.||BMC|
|Wisata Petik Madu||Hariyono, S.E.||Wisata Petik Madu is a beekeeping tour that was founded in 1978 which had the initial objective of providing lessons for beekeepers around the Lawang area but later developed into a tourist location due to the high interest of the community. There are three types of bees (A. Mellifera, A. cerana, and Trigona) that are cultivated at honey-picking tourism sites.||BMC|
|Bee Quest||UNPAD team||Bee Quest is a digital platform for beekeepers integrated throughout the world. Bee Quest application provides various information and all information related to beekeeping so that farmers can develop their business. The impact to be created from this application is to connect local beekeepers with other beekeepers from abroad so that they can exchange information and expand the honey sales market. This application can facilitate communication between beekeepers directly with consumers so consumers can get guarantees of pure honey. In addition, this platform aims to make it easier for customers who are interested in beekeeping to find beekeepers who are scattered throughout the world. So that customers have no trouble finding the nearest producer or beekeeper that can be visited. It also provides a discussion forum between beekeepers, government, academics, business, community and media to share knowledge or information related to beekeeping.||BMC|
|App Beekeeper||UNPAD team||Beekeeper App is an educational application for new beekeepers that contains information about beekeeping by using an interactive and easy to understand approach. Beside developing online applications, App Beekeepers also carry out social activities such as creating social movements in the community by directly educating through workshops and seminars. This application aims to c/p from D2.4assist beekeepers, especially new beekeepers in starting beekeeping. Not only bee farmers will get benefits but also people who have interest in learning about beekeeping.||BMC|
|HOI Jelly Skincare||UNPAD team||Royal Jelly is a food consumed by queen bees that has many benefits, one of which is for beauty. Based on the results of the study mentioned that royal jelly contains vitamins and essential fatty acids that are able to regenerate the skin and contain gelatine, which can make the skin more moisturized and maintained its elasticity so as to prevent aging and wrinkles on the face. Based on this, the opportunity to develop herbal skincare products (skincare) is very promising. The purpose of this business is to help improve the welfare of honey beekeepers in the Bandung area. Also, this product is expected to be a safe cosmetic choice for the skin||BMC|
|Bee A Flower Apps||UNPAD team||Bee Flowers application is a flower calendar for beekeepers in order to be able to plant the main source of bee food in a sustainable manner according to the time of flowering/blooming to prevent feed shortages during the dry season. The availability of pollen and nectar from flowers is very important for bee colonies (pollen is a source of protein, while nectar is a source of energy for bee colonies). Based on this, the Bee Flowers application was made. This application purpose to help beekeepers to plant bee forage according to the time of flowering so bee feed remains available throughout the year. The source of the spring calendar data is obtained from scientific journals and information from experts.||BMC|
|Smart Bee||UNPAD team||Smart Bee Is an application that is able to connect between local bee growers and bee growers around the world. This application will provide the data needed by bee farmers to be able to optimize the production of honey and to be able to sell to consumers practically. What is unique about this application is the ability to monitor the beehives remotely and be able to retrieve data about the health and performance of the bee colony. Besides this application can also be a SAMS supporting application that is able to provide information relating to how to care and also improve SAMS technology. The impact to be created from this application is to connect local beekeepers with other beekeepers from abroad so that they can exchange information.||BMC|
|Bee Virtual Ecosystem (BVE)||UNPAD team||Bee Virtual Ecosystem is a technology-based beekeeping center where bees are cultivated by bee farmers in the Cianjur Regency, which is able to produce the best quality of honey that is monitored virtually through an application with a sound sensor. The output of the Bee Virtual Ecosystem is not only to provide beekeeping products but also offers an innovative learning model for beekeeping that is spawned through publishing scientific journals and also provide access to beekeepers in conducting their beekeeping activities to be monitored virtually but also to ensure access to researchers or academics in doing research. The Bee Virtual Ecosystem is hoped to be a reference for bee research and innovative research for scientists and universities throughout the world. Therefore, BVE is aiming at the target of academics, owners of development technology who will later make a virtual ecological incubator regulating machine, industrial companies to help market the products of beekeeping from BVE.||BMC|
|Ruang Bermadu||UNPAD team||“Ruang Bermadu” was created to aim at educating youth about the benefits and benefits of honey. In addition, “Ruang Bermadu” also educates young people that raising honey bees is not dangerous and has good business opportunities that have an impact on sustainability.
Combined Space is a business idea in the form of a chill out for young people who use honey to become Honey Smoothies that are adapted to the original character of the honey. In addition, the integrated room has a wall of knowledge from the world of beekeeping, indolocal corner for local processed honey products and Live Honey beekeeping, inviting visitors to get the sensation of living with bees in the middle of the city.
|Dilema OK!||UNPAD team||This application is an application made not only to provide access to beekeepers in monitoring the production of honey from their colonies but also to provide access for beekeepers in selling or offering their honey products directly to consumers. So that honey farmers and consumers can directly interact in the transaction process.
This is an application and a tool that is useful for beekeepers to be able to monitor the growth and development of beekeeping. The device will later record data on the extent of honey bee production in producing quality honey, and the results of the data obtained can be accessed through an application that can be downloaded on the Playstore and at the Apple Store. The app not only contains data taken from the tool but also can be a platform for breeders to sell their beekeeping products directly. This application will bring together sellers and consumers, which then results in buying and selling transactions. With this set of Okay Dilemma tools, it is expected to be able to help beekeepers to be more independent and empowered in developing their aquaculture business.
SAMS Business Models in the EU
|Business Model Name and Start-Up Name||Contact Person||Summary||Business Model Canvas|
|Beehive Monitoring System (merged of three SAMS business models: Observe you Hive, Monitoring of Bee Colonies for Queen Breeding, Rent a Hive) by UNIKAS||Sascha Kirchner||There are existing projects which offer to adopt a bee colony https://www.planbeeltd.com/. Usually there is no direct access to the hives rented by the customer. With this HIVE monitoring system, customers could observe all relevant data (weight, flight activity, acoustics) in real time. An additional camera would also be possible. The customers who rent a beehive can always observe their colony and there is a considerable added value compared to an anonymous sponsorship.
The HIVE system can assist beekeepers also in their queen breeding choices. With the help of sensor data, desired breeding traits can be detected earlier and more precisely.
In order to obtain more bee data from different regions, HIVE systems are loaned to interested beekeepers. The received data will be evaluated and can be used by both sides (scientific and application-oriented).
|Software solutions for beekeepers||Armands Kviesis and Aleksejs Zacepins||Development of different software products to aid beekeepers in their beekeeping activities, e.g. DSS SAMS data display for beekeepers/ scientists, beekeeping log, online matchmaking platform for partnerships between beekeepers and technology providers. These products include mobile apps and web services in relation to the beekeeping sector.||BMC|
|Power supply solutions for monitoring systems||Armands Kviesis and Aleksejs Zacepins||Developing power supply options for monitoring systems, e.g. alternative energy solutions (solar power systems, wind power systems). Since monitoring systems can be placed in very remote areas, it is important to provide efficient power solutions, so the monitoring systems could run self-sufficiently by utilizing the alternative energy sources.||BMC|
|3D Case for bee colony monitoring system||Armands Kviesis and Aleksejs Zacepins||Designing and printing the casing for monitoring systems to be used in real environment. Such casing will provide water and dust protection for electronic components and adds aesthetic aspect. Recommended to be further elaborated in combination with the Business Model “Development of printed circuit boards for monitoring systems”.||BMC|
|Development of printed circuit boards for monitoring systems||Armands Kviesis and Aleksejs Zacepins||The business idea is related to designing and printing customized circuit boards (PCB) based on monitoring system specifications. Besides the circuit board printing, this business also provides soldering of the necessary electronic components.
Recommended to be further elaborated in combination with the Business Model “3D Case for bee colony monitoring system”.
|SAMS data warehouse deployment and hosting||Armands Kviesis and Aleksejs Zacepins||The Business is about providing services to deploy and maintain the SAMS Data Warehouse which has been developed during the SAMS project. It also includes user support to link different bee colony monitoring systems with the SAMS Data Warehouse.||BMC|
|HIVE as a flexible monitoring tool||Sascha Kirchner||The HIVE monitoring system is a very flexible sensor monitor system which can also be used for other scientific questions. The system will be equipped with the appropriate sensors and the control software is adapted according to the requirements. An example could be the long-term measurement of nitrate contents of surface waters.||BMC|
|A buzzy lesson – Providing monitoring systems and bee colonies to educational institutions||Kristina Gratzer||Beehives (incl. colonies) with a (SAMS) HIVE monitoring system will be sold to schools, universities, beekeeping training sites or other educational institutions. Depending on the needs of the customers, the start-up manages the sold bee colonies and gives regular talks for the students, or only provides the systems and service in times of needs. The customer buys the product/ service to improve their course offerings, to teach bee biology and to teach the students how to analyse data on a living system right outside the building. The students further learn to interact with social insects and animals in general.||BMC|